AT HOME PETS
  • AT Home Pets Blog
  • About
  • For Sale
    • My Animals for Sale
  • My Wee Littles
    • Expecting
  • My Rabbits
  • Mice
  • Articles
  • Information on Small Animals
    • Buying a Rabbit
    • Medical Advice >
      • Area Rabbit Savvy Veternarians
    • Caring for your rabbit >
      • Feeding Your Rabbit
      • Housing your Rabbit
      • Breeding
    • Caring for Guinea Pigs
    • Rabbit Activities >
      • The Rabbit and it's Uses
    • Articles to read
    • Rabbit Supplies
    • Forums and Organizations
  • Links
    • Clubs
    • Breeders >
      • Canadian breeders
      • Non-Canadian breeders
      • Directories of Breeders
    • Rescues
    • Forums and On-line Sales
    • Breed Information

Where have all the pet stores gone?

5/13/2014

 
Picture
Where Have All The Pet Stores Gone?
by Jacquelyn Fogel

We have been duped. Dog breeders have been used by the Animal Activists in their war on domestic pets. About 25 years ago a small core of Animal Activists who are now in control of all the major national animal rights organizations forged a plan, and we unwittingly helped them out. They started a campaign to close down all pet stores that had live animals in them, knowing full well that the demand for the puppies in these facilities would remain high. Dog breeders helped them. We railed against the nasty pet stores and their supplies of unworthy dogs. We offered up our own well-bred puppies as alternatives, even though we could never meet the demand the public has for puppies. We thought we were taking the high road, and embraced the new animal rights-leaning shelters that wanted to shut down the pet stores. We even put statements into our “codes of ethics” that said we would never allow our puppies to be sold in a pet store. We felt holy.

Never mind that these stores were usually independently owned by small, local business owners who fed their families on the profits from these stores. Never mind that most of the puppies were purchased locally from breeders in our surrounding communities. Never mind that these stores were all regulated locally and federally and at least in theory, inspected by USDA and local health departments. Never mind that these were all legal, profit-making, tax-paying businesses that bought supplies from local vendors and sold to local residents. Never mind that these business owners supported local service organizations and donated to local churches and charities. Never mind that the public still wanted to buy puppies and we hobby breeders were all but invisible to them as we guarded our precious bloodlines from falling into unscrupulous hands. We agreed with the animal activists that these puppies were unhealthy, and the owners of these stores should be punished and put out of business

So where does the public go to buy their puppies now? Pet ownership is at an all-time high, and many of us hobby breeders still have trouble selling our pure bred puppies for what they are actually worth. I’ll tell you where the public is getting their pets from. They are now going to the retail shelters and rescues to find their pets. The small, local breeders that supplied local pet stores are being replaced by commercial kennels far away and invisible. The poorly operated puppy farms are still breeding dogs, they have merely gone further underground. The transportation of puppies from huge kennels and shelters in the south and from places outside this country has ballooned into a multi-million dollar mega-business. Now here’s the real kicker. Most of these retailers of puppies now claim non-profit status. They don’t pay taxes to support their communities any more. They slap the title “rescue” onto what they are doing, and suddenly they are self-righteous saviors of poor mistreated animals rather than brokers and transporters of poorly manufactured products specifically bred to produce a profit. And the public who is “rescuing” these dogs feels holy.
Follow the money. If you ever need to know why something is happening the way it is, and your common sense is telling you the logical signs just don’t add up, follow the money. By shifting the sales of pets from regulated, independent, tax-paying businesses to largely clandestine, non-profit suppliers the animal activists have brilliantly co-opted the very enemy we thought we were fighting against. Realistically all shelters should have been working to put themselves out of business – not the pet stores. They should have done such good work educating the public how to be responsible dog owners that over time there would no longer be a critical need for their services. Obviously that didn’t happen. Here in Wisconsin we recently built a $6.5 million facility that has to have semi-loads of dogs shipped in regularly to keep it stocked. And they can turn-around (sell the entire inventory)their product in about 48 hours. That certainly makes them enough cash to keep the doors open and the lights on. And they don’t pay taxes.

How about this overwhelming push to spay and neuter all dogs? Wow! What a money maker that has become! Now a local individual or their neighbors and friends cannot morally create their own pets because it is unethical to keep their dogs intact. They have to go back to the retail shelter stores to purchase another one. The animal activists have even co-opted the veterinary community into believing that all pets should be spayed and neutered, when, in fact, there is no clinical evidence to support that this is best for every animal. Just now some studies are coming out that say, in fact, the opposite is true. I don’t know why the veterinary community has allowed themselves to be so coopted, unless I follow the money. As my own vet points out, she would be out of business tomorrow if all of the mixed breeds were as healthy as people claim they are. Common sense should be telling us the same thing. If heterogeneity was the answer to perfect health, then humans would be the healthiest species on the face of the planet. And we are not. Genetics work pretty much the same across species.

Does anyone think outside the propaganda anymore? I ask people regularly when they last saw a stray dog in their neighborhood. In northern states it is rare. If a dog is found loose, more often than not, it is a runaway not a stray. Most of the dogs in shelters are surrenders, not strays. And who is surrendering those dogs? Could it be the same population of people who wanted to rescue the ill-tempered, unhealthy puppies they saw in shelters? Everyone wants to be a savior – until it gets expensive, dangerous or just too hard. Then they return the untrained, older dog that now has even more serious issues to a shelter that re-sells it to someone else. When I get a puppy back as an older dog, I usually place the dog in a new home for nothing. And I have to spend time and advertising money screening the new potential owners. The revolving door of sell, surrender, re-sell can become quite profitable if a shelter gets the same amount of money each time they sell the same dog.
This is how far out-of-whack things have gotten in this country. Some time ago I was nominated by a member in one of my national breed clubs to receive a breeder of the year award. The person who actually won the award is a fine breeder in the UK and she does a great job with her dogs. But the primary reason I was eliminated as a contender for the breeder of the year award was because I do not support “rescue,” and had actually written articles about what mixed-breed rescue has become in this country. Silly me. I thought the award was about being a breeder. My dogs don’t go into rescue programs because I take them back or rehome them if at any point in their lives they cannot be kept by their owners. I have started a non-profit, Keep Your Pets, Inc, dedicated to keeping families in crisis together with their pets, but that is not good enough. Apparently it is now not even politically correct for breeders to disparage the concept of rescue as it has evolved in this country. I don’t rescue dogs; I breed and sell them, and sometimes rehome them. And there is nothing wrong with that model.

I am a business owner in a Capitalist, free-market economy. My primary business is boarding and grooming pets, but I also sell well-bred puppies. And I spend a lot of money to produce and market those puppies. I don’t get any tax breaks. I don’t get free dog food or free veterinary care. I don’t ask for my supplies to be donated, I purchase them from local vendors. It’s a good model, and it works for all products, not just automobiles and refrigerators. We get so caught up in the “give a puppy a good home” sob stories that we forget that our dogs are a product, too. I adore my dogs. My children often said I loved the dogs more than I loved them (totally untrue). But it does take a lot of time, wisdom and money to produce healthy, well-socialized purebred puppies. We should not feel guilty about wanting to be compensated for the time it takes us to produce a superior product. By refusing to use the language of commerce to talk about pets, we have somehow placed them in a different logical spot in our brain.

The current suppliers and sellers of puppies are not fooled. They are very clear about the economics of producing, transporting and selling millions of poorly bred and cheaply produced dogs to unwitting customers for a lot of money. They use the language of adoption and rescue, but they follow the economics of a free enterprise, Capitalist system. They may call themselves “non-profit”, but they are making millions of dollars from the distribution and sales of these puppies. Only we hobby breeders have been foolish enough to let our emotional ties to our dogs get in the way of understanding this economic model.

It’s all about supply and demand – and ultimately the demise of domestic pet ownership. Now that shelters and rescues are the last retail places to produce and sell pets, how easy will it be for them to suddenly “expose” the source of all their dogs as nasty puppy farms. Is it too far a stretch to then imagine that they will try to manipulate the emotions they have already sensitized to simply quit demanding these miserable creatures? How better to put someone out of business than to quit demanding their product? Right now, in the animal activist world, it is immoral to own a well-bred purebred, or an unspayed or unneutered dog. If the next step is to say it is immoral to own a dog produced by a puppy farm, they are dangerously close to making all pet ownership immoral. If you don’t think this is the real agenda, then you just are not paying attention.

Personally, I don’t think people will allow themselves to be so completely manipulated by these animal activist evangelists. The general public still loves to own a dog even if they now prefer to call it an adoption. But 15 years ago I would not have foreseen a population that preferred to “rescue” a dog rather than buy one from a good breeder if they could afford it. I also did not see the demise of the local for-profit retail pet stores being replaced by non-profit retail shelters. That change happened much faster than I thought it could. Where have all the retail pet stores gone? We helped to put them out of business, never stopping to realize that we were the next targets in a well-planned campaign to end all pet ownership. It’s time for dog breeders to become activists in support of all people who want to legally breed and work with animals. The activists are picking us off one group at a time. Yesterday the pet stores and circuses, today the Carriage Horses and pig farms, tomorrow the hobby breeders, and the day after that, all breeders of all animals. It’s time to choose sides and get active. There is more to aspire to than the next purple ribbon – a way of life is at stake.

Appeared in Showsight Magazine, March 2014, Volume 22, #8
 
All pictures on this site belong to AT Home Pets. Not for your use. Taking them in THEFT. If you want a picture ask for one.
Heather Petersen link
6/3/2014 04:22:39 am

Well-written post. I breed rabbits and have encountered the anti-breeding wall many times. It's nice to see a new perspective.

annette
6/5/2014 10:48:58 pm

thank you. Someone else wrote it, I just copy and pasted it. :)

Melody
4/6/2015 09:36:59 am

Wow.Thank you for the eye opening point of view. This is not something I had thought about in this way. I support your point of view and it seems so clear now. We've been manipulated and we just smiled our guilty smiles all the way through it. Thanks for making me see things a lot differently.

athomepets
4/6/2015 11:03:17 pm

I know. People just aren't really aware are they?


Comments are closed.

    Author

    I have been breeding rabbits for a quite a few years.  I thoroughly enjoy them as animals and think they make great pets.  I also like to take some of them to rabbit shows to see how they measure up to the standards.

    Picture
    You can find me on Facebook and instagram. 
    Picture
    For the BEST rabbit forum I've ever found.  Go to Rabbittalk.com.  Good for the pet rabbit owner as well as the breeder for meat or show. 
    Follow A Net In Time's board Rabbits on Pinterest.

    Categories

    All
    2012
    2013
    2014
    2015
    2016
    2017
    Abuntay
    Acorn
    Aero Bar
    Aida
    Akara
    Alice
    AliceCherry
    Animal Management
    Animal Management
    Animal Rights
    Animal Welfare
    Aold
    AppleBlossom
    Aria
    Arrow
    Article
    Ascot
    Asia
    August
    AutumnAid
    Baby
    Baccia
    BandAid
    Bandit
    BandSaw
    Basic
    Beamer
    Beethoven
    Bella
    BellaStrand
    Benito
    BerryNose
    Billie
    Birdman
    Biscotti
    Biscuit
    Blaze
    Blaze (LH)
    Blossom
    Blue Lagoon
    BluePond
    BlueStone
    BonFire
    Bonnet
    Branchnook
    Breed Information
    Breeding
    Briarlight
    BrightSong
    BrightSparrow
    BrookAsh
    BrookPond
    BrownBand
    Buck
    Bumblestripe
    ButterBall
    Butterscotched
    Button
    CallsPlay
    Calypso
    Camden
    Captain Crunch
    Carina
    Carma
    Cheeko
    Cheeky
    Chesstine
    Cheta
    Chinpin
    ChocoBane
    CinderFlame
    Cloudtail
    CoalDust
    Companion Oriented
    Companion-oriented
    Contest
    CookieDough
    CookieSprinkles
    Copper
    Corbin
    Creamsicle
    Cross
    Customer Service
    Customer-service
    Cyan-lh
    Daisy-gp
    Daisyhawk
    Daisy-hl
    Dancer
    DanceStep
    Dayle
    Diablo
    Dj
    Dovewing
    DropPatch
    Duskpoppy
    DustDrop
    DustMite
    Dusty
    DustyMIller
    Echo
    Education
    Elsa
    Endorsements
    E Rosie
    Eureka
    Feeding
    Flash Mouse6aab2a8f36
    Flemish-giant
    Footsthebill
    Forest City Rabbit Club
    For Sale
    For-sale
    Gemma
    Georgia
    German
    Gerry
    Gina
    Gogo
    Goldenflower
    Gregory
    Guinea Pigs
    Hailey
    Hairy-spike-gp
    Hallowflight
    HareWing
    Harlequin
    HashBrown
    Health
    Heart's Cry
    Henna
    Holland Lop
    Holland-lop
    Holly
    Hollyleaf-gp
    Honeyfern-gp
    Horatio
    Housing
    Introductions
    Ivypool
    J
    Jack-hl
    Jackson
    Jewel
    Jill
    Jill Jill
    Jolea
    Joyce
    Keener
    Kettle Gpb8ee2be3ac
    Kit-care
    LatteBranch
    Leafblossom
    Lem
    Lena
    LightCinder
    Lil-angel
    LilyBane
    Lilyflower
    Lionstripe
    Lisa
    Litter Born
    Little-dawn
    Logos
    Marbles
    Marie
    Marilla
    Marilyn
    Marilyn'sCharm
    Maximus
    Meat Rabbit
    Meggie
    Merlo
    Merlo-hl
    Mice
    Midnight
    Milkshake
    Mini Rex
    Miscellaneaous
    Miss Q
    Mistyfoot
    Mitch
    Mittens
    Mixed Breed
    Mocha
    Moose
    Mop
    MossBelly
    Mousewhisker
    Natural Feeding
    Nero
    News
    New Zealand
    Nicholas
    Nicky Mouse3df29cf56e
    Nightlily
    Nights-cry
    Nookncranny
    Nutmeg
    Olivia
    OpalBerry
    Oreo
    Oscar
    Peach
    Pearstar
    Peek A Mommy
    Peekamommy2150c5dcc8
    Penny
    Pepper
    Peppin
    Peske
    Petey
    Pet People Pictures
    Peyton
    Pie
    Pinpin
    PistolKeeper
    PistolPete
    Pj
    Poco
    Polish
    PondFlower
    PondPuddle
    Popper
    Poppet
    Potter
    Questions Asked
    Rabbit Show
    Rain
    RainBerry
    Ranger
    RavenSpeck
    Reacher
    Redblaze
    Red-max
    Red-pete
    Rena
    Rescue
    Return
    Risensun
    Rizzo
    Rockfall
    RockSpirit
    Rodney
    Roger
    Rosepetal
    Rosewood
    Rosie-sp
    Rustic
    Sable
    Safety-issues
    Sage
    Sally
    Sandie
    Sandstorm
    Sarge
    SBerry
    Ser-bogs
    Shade
    ShadyBreeze
    Shaya
    SheerTangle
    Shiloh
    Shows
    Sienna
    Silverfrost
    Skipper
    Skitter
    Slip
    Sneak-thief
    Snow
    Snowpelt
    Snow-polish
    Snowshade
    Sold
    Soldier
    Sparkle Eyes
    SparksBranch
    SpeckDrop
    Spice
    SpiceBlossom
    Splash
    SplashHawk
    SplatterBush
    Spotlight
    Spots
    Spottedleaf
    Spottednose-gp
    Sprite
    Standard Rex
    Starburst
    Starflower
    Stevie
    Stolen
    StormLight
    StormSparrow
    Stormy
    Summer
    Sundrop
    Sunnyrock
    Sunshadow
    SunShine
    TangleFoot
    TangleHeart
    TangleWebb
    Tanner
    Tansy
    Tava Gp
    Tawnypelt
    Teddy
    Temp Gp
    Tempy
    ThistleStripe
    Tilly
    Tinker-gp
    Tiny-tim
    Tipper
    TipTop
    Tm-polo1
    Tmueka03-nellie
    Toadfoot-gp
    Toffee-gp
    Toffee Gpafa704b3dc
    Tommy Tit
    Tommy-titpeter
    Tommy Titpeter2ddcb0e531
    Tory
    TraceElement
    Tracey
    Training
    Trebel
    Triscuit
    Usefulness-of-rabbits
    Varia
    Varmints
    Vena
    Vicki
    Violet
    Vivian
    Wafer
    WebbsBeauty
    Website News
    Whiskerheart
    Whiskersong
    William
    Willowsong
    WingFlight
    Winters-coat
    Youtube

    Picture
    Click me to learn more about Rabbits and Guinea pigs

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.